CTRL+K is your friend then.
But if you've lots of albums to do then you can use this autohotkey routine I wrote:
It accepts the dialog without having to press it using the new shortcut CTRL+N. Just make sure you've set the dialog up first they way you like and run it once for them to stick.
Then use AHK script:
;
; Short-cut: CTRL+N
; TRACK turbo Auto-Renumberererer
;
#IfWinActive ahk_exe Mp3tag.exe
^n::
Sleep, 500
send, {LAlt}
send, {o}
send, {Down 1}
send, {enter}
; This next line auto accepts the AR dialog
send, {enter}
Return
#IfWinActive
Instructions on usage: Keyboard shortcuts