I would be a very happy user if the use of functions could be added to the "Filename to Tag" convert option.
I'm not sure if "Text File to Tag" could benefit from the same, but since we already have the option in "Tag to Tag" and "Tag to Filename", why not.
Reasoning is my recent post about how to drop the leading zero from tracknumbers when reading the info from a filename. The offered solution by ohrenkino works, but boy is it convoluted. And I just spent half an hour trying to get the same kind of action working for a different format (I am absolutely not comfortable with RegExp and Guessing Values, so there's that too)
Just a little philosophy:
Functions work on a given string - so you would have to supply the whole string for a function.
When you use the converter Filename-Tag for something like
01 - Abba - Waterloo
with the matching format string like
%track% - %artist% - %title%
but you want to strip the leading zero with
$num(%track%,1)
then %track% does not contain any data at that time as TRACK has to be filled first - and that is what you do, when you assign the pattern in Convert>Filename - Tag.
The same applies to Convert>Textfile - Tag.
See the documentation on the difference between matching and generating format strings:
And in that respect
ask for generating format strings and not matching format strings.
So I would think that the current behaviour is by design.
Honestly I don't see the problem, your argument that TRACK has to be filled first doesn't hold water.
MP3Tag reads the value from disk, and can then execute the function on said value... if needed after storing that value in TRACK.
OK, here is a way to avoid RegExp and functions when a group of file names have consecutive track numbers in an unwanted format:
-
Sort the files as you want them to be numbered and select the group.
-
Do your standard Filename to Tag conversion using the existing tags.
-
Use the Auto-numbering Wizard to replace the unwanted Track tag format with the number format you want.
-
Run Tag to Filename to add the new tag numbers (and your other tags) to the file names.
Four steps but no functions or RegExp. Obviously, this technique only works when the target file tracks are numbered consecutively.
I used this method in my earliest days with Mp3tag when I had no skills with functions or with RegExP.
I can't do anything against that you don't see the problem. Just don't be surprised that a function that needs a string to function does not work if there is no string.
Your description
is absolutely correct: you have to store the value first and then you can execute more or less every action/manipulation on it.
But you said already
The already working method is to use the admittedly in this case more complex action "Guess value"
"Guess value" takes more or less any string and not just the filename for convenience reasons and then allows to prepare that string so that the bits and pieces can be assigned to (other) fields.
So, the only method for the time being, until your feature request is implemented is either go the way with several steps with the existing Convert>Filename-Tag and then further actions or fewer steps with an action of the type "Guess value".which requires a more complex preparation.