[X] Flac-Files: Vorbis Comments Can't be saved


I have some flac files they only habe id2 tags but no vorbis comments (don't ask me how this happend).

Now i want to convert this id3 tags to vorbis comments. In can't do this (would be a new feature of course).

So I wanted to manually enter the tags and save them. This does not work (maybe because the vorbis comment's does not exist at all) - this is the bug.

Thanks a lot for help.



Sorry, but I have no problems with saving Vorbis Comments to FLAC files without tags. Maybe you can provide an example file?

Best regards,


Hi Florian

Here is the file to download (exclusive for you):



Could not send you a PM. So i put the link of the file in the above post.


Hi Olaf,

this files is somehow broken. As you can see in the hex-editor, some app wrote ID3v2 frames behind the fLaC header signature.

Best regards,


Hi Florian

Does this mean that this file is lost?
It's not the only file like this.



Yes, I think so :frowning:

closed #7

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.