[X] WMA: Should "COMMENT" map to "Description" or "WM/Comments"?

As I have no WMA specification at hand, I'm a little unsure if "COMMENT" should really map to "Description" (what kind of field is that?) or to "WM/Comments" because I've seen both.

(Picard uses "WM/Comments", for instance.)

Florian, any hard facts on this?

See MSDN: Attributes for Music Files where Description is listed and WM/Comments is not.

Funny, that you've posted this as bug report.

Thanks for the link.

Well, since I had no specs, I thought this might be the best place (in case it was a bug). And I knew you would know the answer offhand :slight_smile:

Then again, I just found it it in the official »attributes that correspond to ID3 tags« list. I guess that’s also the list MusicBrainz use, have to ask Lukas.

But I agree now that »Description« seems to be the »more general one« and thus should be used in Mp3tag.

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.